GOP Consultant Rick Wilson: Time For Republicans To Move On From Same Sex Marriage Debate

Florida based GOP operative Rick Wilson apparently got into a bit of a squabble with Rush Limbaugh over Wilson’s comments to Politico that the GOP has lost on same sex marriage and needs to move on.

Here’s where the accusations of apostasy to the cause come from: I’m one of a non-trivial number of members of the hated consultant class who think digging in for Culture War 3.0 on gay marriage is politically foolish, culturally stupid and boneheaded electorally.

For the record, I agree with Wilson’s tactical advice. On policy, I’m fine with people voting to allow same sex marriages in their states (judicially imposed same sex marriage is a different story).

Where I disagree with Wilson and many others in the  GOP’s professional political class is what role they should have in setting the GOP agenda. I’m not looking for hills to die on but we need some to fight on, even if they are not easy or popular.

Professional political operatives care mostly about winning elections. This makes perfect sense since that’s what candidates pay them for. Activists however care about winning elections for a purpose, to generate  societal and political outcomes. For the former group, winning is an end in and of itself while for the latter it’s a means to something else. Now this isn’t to say professional operatives don’t have issues they care passionately about or would work for a candidate that they have real qualms about (though I’m sure some would) but  as Wilson himself says, their personal feelings aren’t why they are hired and shouldn’t color their advice to candidates.

Letting consultants guide the morality of the party is good for Republican office holders who care about winning and holding office and bad for people who care more about outcomes. Again, this isn’t a knock on the people who do politics for a living, it’s simply an acknowledgement of reality.

Wilson says in arguing for abandoning this fight, “Cultures change, and ours has. Ignoring reality isn’t principled: it’s pigheaded.” This is all true but it didn’t just happen organically. It happened because Democrats never say, “we lost, give it up forever and move on” as Wilson argues the GOP should do here. Sure there are tactical retreats by Democrats when they don’t have the votes but on the whole Democrats never tell liberals “give it up”. At worst they tell them, “wait”.

For example, Bill Clinton signed welfare reform (after multiple vetoes). Obviously after 15 years of it working, Democrats would never roll it back, would they?

HillaryCare went down in flames in the early 90s. Did the Democrats say, “sorry, guys we’re done. The numbers aren’t there. Never will be and if you keep insisting we as professionals fight this fight, we’re doomed”? ObamaCare suggests that they spent the intervening years fighting and fighting and fighting until they won.

Look at same sex marriage. It was an electoral loser everywhere it was tried (including California and New York!) until 2010. So clearly the Democrats just threw in the towel and acceded to the wishes of the voters as expressed in election after election? Apparently not.

And when liberals say, “Oh no, same sex marriage won’t lead to religious institutions being forced to accept or accommodate same sex couples” we can trust them, right? Oh. But they’ve always been so honest before. Oh. We’ll the left would never use their culture setting machine to push for polygamy. Oh. But they’ve always been so honest about this stuff before. Oh.

Wilson says the GOP should take a pass on fighting Culture War 3.0. Maybe he should tell that to the Democrats who never seem to get that memo or have any interest in stopping.

Another example is amnesty for illegal aliens (yes, it’s amnesty). The party has made it very clear by forcing pro-amnesty candidates McCain and Romney to the right on this issue that as a party voters are opposed to it. Yet without any evidence to support their electoral claims, the GOP professional class has decided to force the policy on the voters.

Again though, Wilson is right. The GOP can’t win these wars because as I’ve written before, it’s not designed to fight them.

Wilson says evangelicals who care about fighting against same sex marriage (but presumably it applies to other parts off the GOP/conservative coalition) “might want to spend some time changing hearts and minds in society at large before you bolt”. I agree with the first part but disagree with the second.

Conservatives of all stripes need to win more “hearts and minds”. We’re a minority in the GOP , let alone the country as a whole. My disagreement is with the order of things. Conservatives of all stripes need to bolt first. The Republican brand is tarnished beyond repair. A party that will stand for nothing but poll reading will never rally people to its ideas or change “hearts and minds”.

This won’t be easy or quick. Stepping back from electoral politics isn’t gong to be easy because in the short term it will likely lead to more Democrats winning. This isn’t a one or two cycle project. The left has been working on this project for 100 years or more. But the cost of “winning” with warmed over Democrats with an R after their name is getting too high. Every day we put off ditching the dead carcass that is the GOP is a day wasted.


About Drew

I blog about politics and hockey because I sort of understand those things. I'd blog about women but I'll never understand them.

Posted on March 29, 2013, in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.

  1. Spot on Drew. I’m hoping more conservatives get over their Stockholm syndrome with the republican establishment.

  2. So I am an engineer and non-evangelical christian (Methodist) but I will stop voting for Repubs if they don’t vigorously oppose gay marriage and immigration amnesty. If the R’s join the D’s on these issues it will be the death of the R’s. Hell I’m investing in guns and ammo, that’s gonna be the most sought after items any way in another 10 years or so.

  3. “Conservatives of all stripes need to win more “hearts and minds”. We’re a minority in the GOP , let alone the country as a whole.”

    Absolutely wrong. You and others like you have bought into the media lie that there are very few conservatives and that it’s time to give up your social issues, and now you’ve turned and are spouting the Left’s message for them, telling the rest of us to let this or that issue go because we’ve lost is, citing that we’re “In the minority”. Since you don’t know what you’re talking about, why on earth should anyone listen to you?

  4. having a patchwork of state laws on this matter is the worst possible solution, whichever side you’re on

    It’s one of those issues where federalism doesn’t really work, you get an absurd mishmash. Either it’s allowed nowhere or its allowed some places —-> a couple moves, sues, and eventually wins at the Supreme Court level. Likely what’ll happen if the Court overturns DOMA and doesn’t rule on Prop 8

  5. BTW when you talk about “ditching the dead carcass of the GOP” what is your new party based around? Cutting spending exclusively? Cuz (and this is not a comment on the dread social issues) that party is not going to be popular. Frankly everyone constantly predicting fiscal apocalypse/mustbalancebudgetimmediately are just as misguided as the soconniest of socons

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: